Book Review:  Caste: The Origins of Our Discontents by Isabel Wilkerson

At first, as I picked up this book and skimmed through it, I asked myself: Do I really want to read about all this trauma and grief? I knew that the experience would be uncomfortable. I realize now, though, that every American should read it. It rips off the shroud of illusion covering up what this country really is: a nation built upon a rigid caste system with white males on top, other races beneath them, and Black people at the bottom of the ladder. Uncomfortable, yes. But understand that I am not speaking of reality here; I am speaking of an artificial construct created by our ancestors whose aim was to keep people they considered inferior in a state of perpetual subjugation. Wilkerson writes that “America has an unseen skeleton, a caste system that is as central to its operation as are the studs and joists that we cannot see in the physical buildings we call home. Caste is the infrastructure of our divisions.” And “in the American caste system, the signal of rank is what we call race, the division of humans on the basis of their appearance.”

So that readers can fully comprehend how caste systems work, Wilkerson compares the American system with the caste system of India and also the caste system during the Third Reich in Nazi Germany. Your initial reaction might be that the caste structure in the United States was never as severe and rigid as in these other cultures, but Wilkerson creates a compelling argument that in some ways it was even worse. Even before the country was founded, slavery was ubiquitous, and after independence, it became locked into the system by law. Black slaves were considered property and had no rights. Families were ripped apart and the individual members sold with impunity; any Black person who did not show proper respect to white people could be tortured and murdered without consequence. Indeed, often entire towns turned out for the “entertainment” of watching supposed transgressors get mutilated and lynched. After the Civil War, when slavery was abolished, and on up to the civil rights movement of the 1960s, unpunished deeds of cruelty and hatred against Black people remained common, especially in the Deep South.

Wilkerson explains that in Africa, people are considered just people; it is only in America or Britain that they become Black as opposed to white. She writes that “geneticists and anthropologists have long seen race as a man-made invention with no basis in science or biology.” But of course these artificial constructs can be devastatingly powerful. In the planning stages of their movement, the Nazis looked to racist America for inspiration on how to turn the minds of the German people to the concept of caste; they studied U.S race laws to help them create legislation against the Jews.

Among the pillars of caste, that is, the foundations that hold it up, Wilkerson delineates supposed divine will and natural law; strict boundaries of marriage and mating (the U.S. retained laws against interracial marriage until well into the twentieth century); the concept of purity of the upper castes; division by occupation; enforcement by terror and cruelty; and cultural mindsets of superiority and inferiority. The book brings out that the violent discrimination taking place today in the States is nothing new, but rather part of an enduring pattern of caste. This pattern has played a role in recent elections, including as a reaction against Obama’s presidency.

To Germany’s credit, it has condemned and erased its Nazi past and memorialized the victims; in contrast and to our shame, many people in the United States honor Confederate slaveholders rather than the enslaved. As Wilkerson points out: “Compared to our counterparts in the developed world, America can be a harsh landscape, a less benevolent society than other wealthy nations. It is the price we pay for our caste system. In places with a different history and hierarchy, it is not necessarily seen as taking away from one’s own prosperity if the system looks out for the needs of everyone.” I can only conclude by fervently agreeing with the last line of the book: “A world without caste would set everyone free.”

As I said above, this is uncomfortable reading, but it is also necessary reading. The U.S. caste system has been in place since long before the country even existed. It hides in plain sight because we are so used to it. Reading this book helps to shatter that delusion and set us on a plain path toward truth.

This entry was posted in Book Reviews and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply